- 516 Update
- Posts
- ⭐ Best Bagel Shops in Nassau County
⭐ Best Bagel Shops in Nassau County
Looking for Nassau’s best bagels? Try local favorites in Levittown, Garden City & East Meadow serving fresh, kettle-boiled perfection daily.
516 Update
July 24, 2025
Whether you're a fan of classic bacon-egg-and-cheese or love your lox with a schmear, nothing beats a fresh, local bagel—and Nassau County has some of the best in the game. From longtime neighborhood staples to hidden gems serving kettle-boiled perfection, we’ve rounded up must-visit bagel shops that locals rave about. Expect crisp exteriors, fluffy centers, and flavors worth the carbs.
TURNPIKE BAGELS DELI & BAKERY 🥯 | ⭐ Rating: 4.6 (Google) |
"I have been coming here for YEARS and it is HANDS DOWN the best bagel store around. Even when I bring their bagels to someone's house, they always say, 'Where did you get THESE??? They are SO good.' We have also catered food over the years and had BBQ services years ago and we have NEVER been disappointed. You will NOT be disappointed if you come here."
MY THREE SONS BAGEL CAFE (FRANKLIN AVE)🥯 | ⭐ Rating: 4.5 (Google) |
“Fast service. The bagel options were plentiful. Hard to pick what I wanted. I had the bacon egg and cheese truffle on a asiago bagel. Very good and filling. Affordable.”
THE BAGEL PLACE🥯 | ⭐ Rating: 4.6 (Google) |
“We ordered a catered breakfast from The Bagel Place. The person I placed the order with, Joshua was so great and got our order exactly correct. Thank you Joshua! The bagels, muffins, breakfast pasties, fruit and coffee were all fresh and delicious and were packaged perfect for transport to us. Delivery was on time and the delivery person even had a cart to roll in all the catered food. 5 Star Review for this place. I will be ordering from The Bagel Place, Inc in East Meadow for all of our future breakfast meeting orders!”
No matter your bagel style—classic and chewy, bold and loaded, or warm and toasted to perfection—Nassau County has a spot that hits the mark. These local favorites aren’t just places to grab breakfast—they’re part of the community, serving comfort one bagel at a time.
🥯 Did we miss your favorite? Let us know and we might just add it to our next list!