Best Pizza in Nassau County, NY: Top Spots Loved by Locals

Welcome, Nassau County neighbors! If there's one thing we can all agree on, it's that finding the perfect slice is a serious business. With so many amazing pizzerias dotting our towns, from the shores of Long Beach to the streets of Hicksville, the quest for the absolute best pizza in Nassau County can be a delicious challenge. This isn't just another list; it's a guide for locals, by locals.

We’ve done the tasty research for you, creating a definitive guide based on independent research and community recommendations. Whether you're craving a classic New York slice, a crispy Sicilian square, an authentic wood-fired Neapolitan pie, or a creative artisan pizza from a family-owned shop, your search ends here. Get ready to explore the Nassau County pizza spots that residents truly love and uncover your next favorite pie.

1. Umberto's of New Hyde Park

A true Long Island legend, Umberto's of New Hyde Park is more than just a pizzeria; it's a culinary landmark. Famous for its iconic Grandma pizza—a crispy, thin-crust Sicilian topped with chunky tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and a whisper of garlic and basil—this spot has set the standard for generations. The bustling atmosphere, combined with the aroma of baking dough and savory sauces, makes for an unforgettable and authentic experience.

• Must-Try Items:

  • The Original Grandma Pizza

  • Sicilian Slice

  • Vodka Pizza

📍 Location: New Hyde Park, Nassau County, NY

Why It Made the List: Locals love Umberto's for its unwavering consistency and the legendary status of its Grandma pie, which many consider the original and the best on Long Island.

2. Gino's of Long Beach

Gino's is a Long Beach institution, serving classic, foldable New York-style slices just steps from the boardwalk for decades. It's the quintessential post-beach meal and a reliable go-to for family pizza night. Known for its perfectly balanced, slightly sweet sauce and high-quality mozzarella on a crispy-yet-chewy crust, it’s a beloved destination for both beachgoers and Long Beach residents.

• Must-Try Items:

  • Classic Cheese Slice

  • Sicilian Slice

  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza

📍 Location: Long Beach, Nassau County, NY

Why It Made the List: Its iconic status and unwavering commitment to the perfect New York slice make it a cornerstone of the community and a benchmark for Long Island pizza.

3. Salvatore's Coal Oven Pizzeria

For those seeking a taste of pizza history, Salvatore's in Port Washington delivers an authentic experience with its magnificent coal-fired oven. This method produces a uniquely crispy, slightly charred crust that's impossible to replicate. The pizzeria has a cozy, classic vibe, focusing on high-quality ingredients and time-honored techniques that make every pie a masterpiece.

• Must-Try Items:

  • Traditional Margherita Pizza

  • The Original Coal Oven Pizza (with your choice of toppings)

  • Arugula & Prosciutto Pizza

📍 Location: Port Washington, Nassau County, NY

Why It Made the List: Salvatore's is celebrated for its distinctive coal-oven char and flavor, offering one of the most unique and delicious pizza experiences in Nassau County.

4. Eddie's Pizza

An absolute icon since 1941, Eddie's Pizza in New Hyde Park is famous for its "bar pie," a super-thin crust pizza with a cracker-like crispiness. The sauce is spread right to the edge, and the toppings are placed underneath the cheese, creating a unique texture and flavor profile. It's a nostalgic spot with a retro vibe that has been a family favorite for generations of Nassau County residents.

• Must-Try Items:

  • The Original Pizza "Slightly Burnt" (as recommended)

  • The Salad Pizza

  • Sausage & Mushroom Pizza

📍 Location: New Hyde Park, Nassau County, NY

Why It Made the List: Eddie's offers a one-of-a-kind bar pie that is a beloved local tradition, standing out for its incredibly thin, crispy crust and nostalgic charm.

5. Grimaldi's Pizzeria

Located in the heart of Garden City, Grimaldi's brings its legendary coal-brick oven pizza to Nassau County. Known for its smoky, crisp crust and fresh ingredients like "fior di latte" mozzarella and San Marzano tomatoes, it delivers a high-end pizzeria experience. The sophisticated yet family-friendly atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for both a date night and a group outing.

• Must-Try Items:

  • Traditional Pizza (with pepperoni)

  • White Pizza with Garlic

  • Prosciutto & Arugula Pizza

📍 Location: Garden City, Nassau County, NY

Why It Made the List: Grimaldi’s provides one of the most consistently excellent coal-fired pizzas on Long Island, famed for its high-quality ingredients and signature crispy crust.

6. King Umberto

Not to be confused with its New Hyde Park cousin, King Umberto in Elmont is a legend in its own right, earning national acclaim for its creative and delicious pies. While serving fantastic traditional pizza, this spot is famous for its specialty creations, especially the Fried Capellini Pie. It’s a classic Italian restaurant and pizzeria that has been a cornerstone of the community for decades.

• Must-Try Items:

  • Fried Capellini Pie

  • Grandma Pizza

  • Spedini Slice

📍 Location: Elmont, Nassau County, NY

Why It Made the List: Locals and food critics alike flock here for its award-winning, inventive specialty pies that you simply can't find anywhere else.

7. Phil's Pizzeria & Restaurant

A beloved neighborhood institution in Massapequa, Phil's Pizzeria serves up some of the most reliable and delicious New York-style pizza around. This family-owned spot is known for its perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio, generous toppings, and a crust that hits the sweet spot between chewy and crisp. It's a bustling, friendly place that truly feels like the heart of the community.

• Must-Try Items:

  • Regular Cheese Slice

  • Grandma Sicilian

  • Chicken Marsala Pizza

📍 Location: Massapequa, Nassau County, NY

Why It Made the List: Phil's is the quintessential neighborhood pizzeria, adored by locals for its consistently fantastic slices and warm, welcoming atmosphere.

8. Nick's Pizza

Nestled in Rockville Centre, Nick's Pizza is celebrated for its commitment to classic, thin-crust pizza made with exceptionally fresh ingredients. The vibe is old-school and welcoming, with a focus on quality over quantity. Their pies are known for a light, crisp crust that lets the bright, flavorful sauce and high-quality mozzarella shine through, making it a favorite for pizza purists.

• Must-Try Items:

  • Large Plain Pie (a must for first-timers)

  • Mushroom and Sausage Pizza

  • The "Nick's Special" Salad

📍 Location: Rockville Centre, Nassau County, NY

Why It Made the List: Nick's has earned a loyal following for its perfectly executed, no-frills thin-crust pizza that emphasizes freshness and flavor above all else.

9. Lia's Pizzeria

Lia's Pizzeria in Oceanside is a local gem that consistently delivers top-notch specialty slices and classic pies. This spot is known for its creative and generously topped pizzas, from the tangy Buffalo chicken to the savory chicken bacon ranch. The crust is sturdy enough to hold the toppings yet maintains a satisfying chew, making it a go-to for anyone searching for "pizza near me Nassau County."

• Must-Try Items:

  • Buffalo Chicken Slice

  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

  • Baked Ziti Slice

📍 Location: Oceanside, Nassau County, NY

Why It Made the List: Locals love Lia's for its incredible variety and quality of specialty slices, ensuring there's always something new and delicious to try.

10. Vincent's Clam Bar

While famous for its legendary red sauce and Italian-American classics, Vincent's Clam Bar in Carle Place also makes an incredible pizza. Their pies are made with the same attention to quality that defines the rest of their menu, featuring a rich, flavorful sauce and premium toppings. It’s the perfect place to grab a pizza alongside some of the best pasta and seafood dishes in Nassau County.

• Must-Try Items:

  • Margherita Pizza

  • Vincent's Original Pizza

  • White Pizza

📍 Location: Carle Place, Nassau County, NY

Why It Made the List: Vincent's offers a high-quality, restaurant-style pizza that stands up to its legendary reputation, making it a fantastic choice for a complete Italian feast.

🍕 Final Thoughts

Exploring the diverse and delicious world of Nassau County pizza spots is a journey worth taking. From iconic Grandma slices in New Hyde Park to classic boardwalk pizza in Long Beach, each of these local gems tells a story of tradition, family, and community. We encourage you to get out there, try a new spot, and support the small businesses that make our neighborhoods so flavorful. The debate over the best pizza in Nassau County will never end, and that's exactly what makes it so fun.

Want to discover more local news and hidden gems? Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest updates, or check out our community events page to see what's happening in your town.