- 516 Update
- Posts
- Top Christmas Tree Farms Long Island NY for 2025 – Family Favorites
Top Christmas Tree Farms Long Island NY for 2025 – Family Favorites
516 Update
September 11, 2025
The crisp winter air, the scent of fresh pine, and the family adventure of finding the perfect centerpiece for your holiday celebrations are timeless traditions. For those of us in Nassau and Suffolk counties, visiting one of the many Christmas tree farms Long Island NY offers is a cherished event, marking the true start of the season. The experience is more than just about the tree; it's about creating lasting memories with family and friends.
Whether you're searching for a large U-cut field to saw down your own Fraser fir, a festive farm with hayrides and hot cocoa, or a reliable nursery with a wide selection of precut trees, the Island has a spot that matches your holiday style. This guide is here to simplify your search. We've created a curated list of the best farms, from the North Fork to western Suffolk, to help you plan your perfect outing.
Inside, you'll find all the information you need about each location. We'll outline the types of trees available, operating hours, pricing details, and any special attractions or activities offered. Consider this your personal guide to finding the ideal evergreen that will brighten your home this holiday season.
1. Elwood Pumpkin & Christmas Tree Farm
For those in western Suffolk or Nassau County, Elwood Pumpkin & Christmas Tree Farm provides one of the most accessible and traditional choose-and-cut experiences. As Long Island’s westernmost cut-your-own farm, its Huntington location is convenient for city dwellers and suburban families seeking an authentic farm day without a long drive east.
The farm is known for its straightforward, classic approach. You won’t find elaborate holiday festivals here; the focus is purely on the trees. This makes it an ideal spot for visitors who want a simple, nostalgic outing centered on finding the perfect evergreen. Their dedication to the cut-your-own tradition is a major draw for families wanting to create lasting memories.
What to Expect
Elwood offers a robust selection of both cut-your-own and precut trees. The fields feature Douglas Fir trees that you can harvest yourself, while the precut section includes a wider variety like Fraser Fir, Turkish Fir, and various Spruces. Their most unique offering is the availability of exceptionally large trees, with some reported to be over 20 feet tall, a rare find on the island.
Insider Tip: The farm operates on a cash-only basis, so be sure to visit an ATM before you arrive. Although they provide assistance with netting and tying the tree to your car, you must bring your own hand saw. Chainsaws and axes are strictly prohibited.
Key Details & Planning
Feature | Details |
|---|---|
Location | 1500 E Jericho Turnpike, Huntington, NY 11743 |
Tree Options | Cut-Your-Own (Douglas Fir) & Precut (Fraser, Turkish, Spruce) |
What to Bring | Cash, your own hand saw, gloves, and sturdy footwear. |
Pros | Convenient location, true cut-your-own experience, rare large trees. |
Cons | Cash only, must bring your own saw. |
This farm is one of the best Christmas tree farms Long Island NY has for a no-fuss, traditional experience. Its easy access and focus on quality trees make it a perennial favorite.
Learn More: https://elwoodpumpkinfarm.com
2. Lewin Farms – Baiting Hollow Nursery
As one of Long Island's most historic and expansive farms, Lewin Farms offers a comprehensive Christmas tree experience that feels like a true East End tradition. This fourth-generation family farm in Calverton provides one of the largest cut-your-own operations, spanning vast fields that allow visitors to explore and find their ideal tree without feeling crowded.
The farm distinguishes itself with its thoughtful amenities and broad selection, making the entire process smooth and enjoyable. From tractor rides that transport you to distant fields to providing on-site tree wrapping, Lewin Farms focuses on convenience. Its long-standing reputation and large scale make it a destination for families who return year after year for the full farm experience.
What to Expect
Lewin Farms boasts an impressive variety of trees. Visitors can cut their own Douglas Fir, Blue Spruce, Norway Spruce, and White Pine. A unique highlight is the option to purchase live balled trees, perfect for those who want to plant their Christmas tree in their yard after the holidays. The farm also has a large selection of beautiful precut Fraser Firs available.
Insider Tip: The fields are extensive, so wear comfortable, sturdy footwear suitable for walking on uneven terrain. The tractor rides are a huge help, but you'll still be doing a fair amount of walking to find that perfect tree.
Key Details & Planning
Feature | Details |
|---|---|
Location | 812 Sound Ave, Calverton, NY 11933 |
Tree Options | Cut-Your-Own (Douglas Fir, Blue Spruce, Norway Spruce, White Pine), Precut (Fraser Fir), and Live Balled Trees. |
Amenities | Tractor transport to fields, on-site wrapping, twine provided. |
Pros | Huge selection and acreage, live balled trees for planting, convenient amenities like tractor rides. |
Cons | Opening dates can vary seasonally, customers are responsible for tying trees to their cars. |
For a classic outing that combines variety and convenience, Lewin Farms is one of the premier Christmas tree farms Long Island NY has to offer. Its scale and family-run charm create a memorable holiday adventure.
Learn More: https://www.lewinfarm.com/christmas-trees/
3. Santa’s Christmas Tree Farm LI
For those looking to make a full day of their tree-cutting adventure, Santa’s Christmas Tree Farm LI in Cutchogue is a standout North Fork destination. Spread across 28 acres, this farm transforms the task of finding a tree into a festive, activity-packed experience. It’s the ideal choice for families who want more than just a tree; they want a day filled with holiday magic, from hayrides to hot cocoa.
This farm stands out as a one-stop holiday hub. Unlike simpler farms focused solely on trees, Santa’s offers a sprawling Christmas shop, numerous family-friendly activities, and an immersive atmosphere. Its location in the heart of Long Island's wine country also allows visitors to combine their trip with other local attractions, making it a true day-trip destination. The farm's approach makes it one of the most popular Christmas tree farms Long Island NY offers for a complete holiday outing.
What to Expect
Santa’s offers a wide selection of choose-and-cut trees, including Douglas Fir, and a variety of precut Fraser Firs. The experience is enhanced with a host of attractions that make it a festive event. Families can enjoy hayrides, pony rides, a synthetic ice rink, and even purchase s'mores kits to roast over fire pits. The large on-site Christmas shop is a major draw, filled with unique decorations, ornaments, wreaths, and gifts. The farm is well-known for hosting various special events throughout the season, which you can find out more about in guides to Long Island Christmas events.
Insider Tip: This farm is extremely popular, especially on weekends in early December. Arrive early in the day to avoid the biggest crowds and get the best selection of trees. Check their website or social media before you go, as they occasionally have strict dog policies allowing only service animals.
Key Details & Planning
Feature | Details |
|---|---|
Location | 30105 Main Rd, Cutchogue, NY 11935 |
Tree Options | Cut-Your-Own (Douglas Fir) & Precut (Fraser Fir) |
Activities | Hayrides, pony rides, synthetic ice rink, fire pits with s'mores, large Christmas shop. |
Pros | All-in-one holiday experience, tons of family activities, large gift shop, beautiful North Fork setting. |
Cons | Can get very crowded, dog policy may be restrictive some years. |
This farm is the perfect choice for families seeking a memorable holiday experience that goes beyond just picking out a tree.
Learn More: https://www.santaschristmastreefarmli.com
4. Shamrock Christmas Tree Farm
For a festive North Fork experience that blends tree hunting with holiday entertainment, Shamrock Christmas Tree Farm in Mattituck is a standout destination. This farm captures the spirit of the season by offering more than just evergreens; it provides a full-fledged family outing complete with activities that make the trip east feel like a mini-holiday festival.
It stands out for its lively, family-friendly atmosphere, especially on weekends. While the core mission is finding the perfect tree, Shamrock enhances the experience with attractions like train rides and local wine tastings. This makes it a perfect choice for families looking to create an entire day of memories, rather than just a quick stop for a tree.
What to Expect
Shamrock offers a beautiful selection of cut-your-own Douglas Firs and a wide variety of precut Fraser Firs. For those looking for a tree that lasts beyond the season, they also have potted and live trees available. Beyond the fields, their on-site shop is stocked with beautifully crafted wreaths, roping, and other holiday décor to complete your home's festive look.
On weekends, the farm comes alive with added attractions. Weather permitting, visitors can enjoy antique train rides through the fields and even sample wines from local North Fork vineyards. This blend of classic farm activities and local flavor makes it a unique stop.
Insider Tip: The farm can get very busy on peak weekends. Arrive early in the day to avoid the largest crowds and get the best selection of trees. Keep in mind that some of the extra activities, like the train rides, are weather-dependent, so check conditions before you go.
Key Details & Planning
Feature | Details |
|---|---|
Location | 20685 Main Rd, Mattituck, NY 11952 |
Tree Options | Cut-Your-Own (Douglas Fir) & Precut (Fraser Fir), Potted/Live Trees |
Activities | Train rides, local wine tastings (weekends, weather permitting). |
Pros | Festive atmosphere with family activities, great selection of trees and décor, supports local vineyards. |
Cons | Can be very crowded on weekends, some activities are weather-dependent, pets are typically not allowed. |
This location is easily one of the most vibrant Christmas tree farms Long Island NY offers, ideal for those seeking a joyful and activity-filled holiday outing.
Learn More: https://www.shamrockchristmastreefarm.com
5. Tilden Lane Farm
For a truly historic and heartwarming holiday experience, Tilden Lane Farm in Greenlawn is a cherished destination. Operating on land farmed by the same family since 1793, this farm offers a genuine step back in time. Its convenient location in western Suffolk County makes it an easy trip for many Nassau residents seeking a traditional cut-your-own outing without the long drive east.
The farm’s charm lies in its simplicity and deep-rooted family tradition. Unlike larger, more commercial operations, Tilden Lane focuses on the core activity: finding and cutting your tree. The friendly staff, often family members, provide a warm welcome and helpful assistance, enhancing the authentic, community-focused atmosphere. They also offer beautiful, handcrafted wreaths and local honey, perfect for holiday gifting.
What to Expect
Tilden Lane Farm provides a classic, hands-on cut-your-own experience. The farm supplies saws, so you don't need to bring your own. After you've selected and cut your perfect tree, the staff offers complimentary netting and will help you securely tie it to your vehicle for the journey home. Due to its popularity and limited supply, it is one of the farms that tends to sell out early in the season.
Insider Tip: The farm operates on a cash-only or local check basis, so plan accordingly. Their operating schedule is very specific, typically limited to a few weekends between Thanksgiving and Christmas, so be sure to check their website for exact dates and hours before you go.
Key Details & Planning
Feature | Details |
|---|---|
Location | 43 Wyckoff Street, Greenlawn, NY 11740 |
Tree Options | Limited Cut-Your-Own & some Precut options. |
What to Bring | Cash or local check, gloves, and appropriate outdoor footwear. |
Pros | Historic family farm atmosphere, saws provided, helpful staff, locally made wreaths. |
Cons | Limited tree supply sells out quickly, cash/check only, no public restrooms. |
Tilden Lane is one of the most authentic Christmas tree farms Long Island NY can offer, perfect for families who value tradition over spectacle. Visiting this historic site is a great local activity, much like other unique Long Island destinations you can explore throughout the year.
Learn More: https://www.tildenlanefarm.com
6. Zuhoski Farms
Nestled on the North Fork, Zuhoski Farms offers a sprawling, authentic farm experience perfect for a scenic holiday outing. Spanning 70 acres with 15 dedicated to Christmas trees, this family-run nursery in Cutchogue provides a classic choose-and-cut adventure. It’s an ideal destination for those looking to make a day of their tree-hunting trip while enjoying the picturesque landscape of Long Island's wine country.
The farm distinguishes itself with its straightforward, family-friendly atmosphere and a commitment to the traditional tree-cutting process. Visitors can wander through acres of Douglas firs to find their perfect match, creating cherished memories along the way. Their on-site seasonal shop, filled with handcrafted wreaths and holiday decor, adds a charming touch to the visit, allowing families to pick up all their evergreen decorations in one place.
What to Expect
Zuhoski Farms focuses exclusively on the cut-your-own experience, with fields brimming primarily with Douglas Firs. The farm provides saws, so you don't need to bring your own tools. Staff are on hand, especially on weekends, to help you cut, carry, and net your tree for free, making the process smooth and hassle-free.
Insider Tip: The farm is historically dog-friendly, but it's always best to call ahead and confirm the policy for the current season. Also, while they are open on weekdays, the full team of helpers is typically available on weekends, which is the best time to go for assistance.
Key Details & Planning
Feature | Details |
|---|---|
Location | 12025 Oregon Rd, Cutchogue, NY 11935 |
Tree Options | Cut-Your-Own (primarily Douglas Fir) |
What to Bring | Sturdy footwear for walking the fields, gloves, and a camera. |
Pros | Saws provided, dog-friendly (check first), scenic North Fork location. |
Cons | Weekday assistance can be limited, single tree variety for cutting. |
For a true countryside outing, Zuhoski is one of the premier Christmas tree farms Long Island NY can offer, combining a vast selection with the charm of the North Fork.
Learn More: https://zuhoskitreefarm.com
7. Hicks Nurseries
For those who prioritize variety, quality, and a comfortable shopping experience over a traditional farm setting, Hicks Nurseries is a standout holiday destination. As Long Island's largest and oldest garden center, this Westbury institution transforms into a winter wonderland, offering a vast selection of premium fresh-cut trees and one of the most extensive collections of holiday décor available anywhere. It’s the perfect choice for families who want a guaranteed perfect tree without the mud and saws.
The major draw of Hicks is its sheer scale and reliability. Instead of wandering a field, you can browse thousands of perfectly shaped Fraser and Balsam Firs, all stood up and displayed for easy inspection in a well-lit, festive environment. This retail approach ensures you know exactly what you're getting, making it an efficient and enjoyable outing, especially for those with specific size and shape requirements.
What to Expect
Hicks Nurseries offers an impressive assortment of fresh-cut Christmas trees, primarily featuring popular varieties like Fraser and Balsam Firs in sizes ranging up to and over 12 feet tall. Beyond natural trees, their showroom boasts one of Long Island’s biggest selections of pre-lit artificial trees and a dazzling array of lights, ornaments, and holiday decorations. Expert staff are always on hand to help you choose, and a convenient local delivery service is available across Long Island and into the NYC area. This makes it a great one-stop shop for all holiday needs.
Insider Tip: Visit on a weekday to avoid the large weekend crowds. Take time to walk through their entire Christmas display; it’s a local tradition and provides fantastic decorating inspiration. Also, ask about their tree recycling tips for after the holidays.
Key Details & Planning
Feature | Details |
|---|---|
Location | 100 Jericho Turnpike, Westbury, NY 11590 |
Tree Options | Fresh-cut (Fraser Fir, Balsam Fir) & one of LI's largest artificial selections. |
What to Bring | Your holiday shopping list; they provide everything else. |
Pros | Huge variety, reliable quality, weather-proof shopping, expert staff, delivery. |
Cons | Not a farm experience (purely retail), delivery is local only. |
This historic nursery is one of the best choices for Christmas tree farms Long Island NY when a premium, hassle-free experience is the goal. For more updates and local news from the area, you can learn more about what's happening at Hicks Nurseries on 516update.com.
Learn More: https://hicksnurseries.com
7 Christmas Tree Farms Comparison - Long Island, NY
Farm / Nursery | Implementation Complexity 🔄 | Resource Requirements ⚡ | Expected Outcomes 📊 | Ideal Use Cases 💡 | Key Advantages ⭐ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Elwood Pumpkin & Christmas Tree Farm | Moderate: Hand saw only, no power tools allowed | Low: Bring own saw, cash only | High: Large trees up to 30 ft available | True cut-your-own experience for western/central Long Island and NYC visitors | Large-size trees, netting & tie-to-car help |
Lewin Farms – Baiting Hollow Nursery | Moderate: Tractor transport, extensive acreage | Moderate: Tractor service, twine and wrapping provided | High: Broad selection including live balled trees | Large-scale U-cut program & family farm tradition | Extensive acreage, live trees for replanting |
Santa’s Christmas Tree Farm LI | Low: Choose-and-cut with family activities | Moderate: Seasonal events, holiday shop | High: One-stop holiday outing with activities | Family-friendly holiday destination combining shopping and events | Seasonal events, clear opening info |
Shamrock Christmas Tree Farm | Low to Moderate: Cut-your-own with weekend events | Moderate: Weekend entertainment & on-site shop | Moderate to High: Fun atmosphere, combined shopping and entertainment | Festive weekend outings with wine tastings and train rides | Seasonal entertainment, daily peak hours |
Tilden Lane Farm | Low: Traditional cut-your-own with saws provided | Low: Limited supply, free netting & tie-to-car help | Moderate: Limited supply, farm atmosphere | Small-scale, traditional farm experience with local products | Historic farm, friendly staff, farm honey |
Zuhoski Farms | Low to Moderate: Staff assistance, saws provided | Moderate: Helpers present on weekends and some weekdays | High: True cut-your-own with daily hours | North Fork cut-your-own with seasonal shop offerings | Dog-friendly, straightforward pricing |
Hicks Nurseries | Low: Retail purchase, no cutting required | High: Large inventory, delivery services | High: Reliable supply, wide tree & décor selection | Customers preferring retail shopping with expert advice | Largest selection, weather-proof retail |
Making Your Holiday Bright and Local
Choosing the perfect Christmas tree on Long Island is a cherished tradition, transforming a simple holiday task into a memorable family adventure. This guide has journeyed through some of the best Christmas tree farms Long Island NY has to offer, each providing a unique and festive experience. From the rustic, hands-on charm of U-cut farms to the all-inclusive holiday wonderlands, the perfect setting for your family's tradition is waiting right here in our community.
The key to a successful outing is preparation. Before bundling up the family, always check the farm's official website or social media pages for the most current information. Hours can change, tree availability can fluctuate, and special events might be scheduled that you won't want to miss. A quick phone call can save you time and ensure the specific tree type or activity you're looking forward to is available.
Selecting the Right Farm for Your Family
Your ideal farm depends entirely on the experience you want to create. To help you make the best choice, consider what matters most for your holiday outing:
For the Traditional U-Cut Experience: If your family loves the thrill of the hunt and the satisfaction of cutting your own tree, farms like Elwood Pumpkin & Christmas Tree Farm and Lewin Farms are excellent choices. They offer a classic, no-frills agricultural experience focused on finding and harvesting the perfect tree.
For All-Day Family Fun: If you're looking for more than just a tree, destinations like Santa’s Christmas Tree Farm LI and Hicks Nurseries are packed with activities. With visits from Santa, train rides, and extensive holiday shops, these locations offer a full day of festive entertainment perfect for families with young children.
For a Quaint and Historic Atmosphere: To step back in time and enjoy a more serene outing, consider Tilden Lane Farm. Its historic setting provides a peaceful backdrop for creating quiet, lasting memories away from the larger crowds.
For a Wide Variety of Pre-Cut Trees: If convenience is key but you still want quality and freshness, Zuhoski Farms and Shamrock Christmas Tree Farm boast impressive selections of pre-cut trees. This allows you to find the ideal shape and size without the effort of sawing it yourself.
Ultimately, the best Christmas tree farms Long Island NY residents can visit are the ones that bring joy and a sense of community. By choosing to shop at these local farms, you are not just buying a tree; you are supporting Long Island's agricultural heritage and investing in the small businesses that make our home special. This simple choice helps keep local traditions alive for future generations to enjoy. We hope this guide empowers you to find the perfect tree and create wonderful holiday memories that will last a lifetime.
For more guides on the best local businesses, family activities, and hidden gems across Nassau County, stay connected with 516 Update. We are your go-to source for everything that makes our community a wonderful place to live and celebrate. Discover your next local adventure at 516 Update.