Muttontown Estate for Rent – $22,000/mo in Jericho School District

If you're searching for a luxury home rental in Muttontown that blends timeless beauty, privacy, and ease—look no further than 10 Hidden Pond. Tucked away at the very end of a quiet, tree-lined road, this historic Georgian Colonial offers a one-of-a-kind lifestyle in the coveted Jericho School District.

Available now for lease at $22,000/month, this estate isn't just a place to live—it's a chance to enjoy the elegance and freedom of stress-free luxury living on Long Island’s legendary Gold Coast.

What’s Included? Practically Everything.

Your monthly rent covers more than just a stunning 5,547 sq. ft. home on over 4 acres. It delivers a lifestyle curated for comfort and peace of mind:

• All utilities: water, electricity, gas, and Wi-Fi

• Full grounds maintenance, landscaping & snow removal

• Pool opening and closing

• Organic mosquito treatments

• Garbage pickup (twice weekly)

• New 14-zone sprinkler system, maintained by landlord

• Use of the attached 3-car garage

• And even direct access to private equestrian and hiking trails—right from your backyard

Everything is set up so you can simply move in and enjoy.

Step Inside: A Home That Tells a Story

Cross a wooden bridge over the tranquil “hidden pond,” and you're greeted by a grand, white-washed brick façade with the original arched front door and a recently restored tricolor slate roof.

Inside, the home is rich in character and modernized for today’s lifestyles:

• A dramatic two-story foyer with a gold-domed ceiling

• Original dentil moldings, wood-burning fireplaces, and pristine hardwood floors from 1938

• Formal living & dining rooms, a heated solarium, library, and guest suite

• A sunlit eat-in kitchen with stainless appliances, granite island, pantry, wet bar, and patio access

Upstairs

• A luxurious primary suite with fireplace, tray ceiling, and a Carrera marble spa bathroom (soaking tub + rain shower)

• Four additional bedrooms (two connected by Jack-and-Jill, two sharing a hall bath)

• A separate home office

Lower Level

• High ceilings, a large fireplace, wet bar, game room, gym, full bath, laundry, and ample storage

• Perfect for entertaining or creating a personal wellness retreat

Outdoor Living That Rivals a Resort

• Oversized bluestone patio and heated in-ground pool

• A picturesque rose garden and walkable pathways

• A natural, one-acre pond (no liner—fish hibernate each winter)

• Basketball hoop, built-in playset, and access to equestrian trails

• Detached 2-car garage (available for an additional fee)

• Fully furnished option also available

This is Long Island real estate at its finest—private, elegant, and designed for indoor-outdoor living year-round.

Meet the Experts Behind the Listing: Team Bona Fide

Your guides to this extraordinary opportunity are Melanie Kalmaer and Jesse Valladares, Licensed Associate Real Estate Brokers and founders of Team Bona Fide. Recently merged with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Laffey International Realty, they bring nearly 40 years of combined experience in luxury, investment, and commercial real estate.

But what truly sets them apart is their role as real estate consultants for life.

Coming January: Everything Long Island Podcast

This winter, Team Bona Fide launches their own YouTube podcast: Everything Long Island. Expect interviews, expert tips, and lifestyle insights across the island’s most desirable communities—including inside access to standout listings like 10 Hidden Pond.

✨ Ready to Experience Gold Coast Living Without the Commitment?

📍 Address: 10 Hidden Pond, Muttontown NY 11545
📞 Jesse Valladares: 516.360.4516
📞 Melanie Kalmaer: 917.400.6506
📧 Email: [email protected]
🌐 Visit: www.BonaFideFHE.com