7 Top Seafood Restaurants Nassau County Guide for 2025

Nassau County's extensive coastline offers more than just scenic views; it's the gateway to some of Long Island's most incredible seafood. From classic South Shore clam shacks to elegant North Shore dining rooms, finding the perfect spot can be a delicious challenge. This guide is designed to cut through the noise, presenting a curated roundup of the best seafood restaurants in Nassau County. We move beyond simple lists to provide a comprehensive look at what makes each establishment unique.

This article is your direct resource for navigating the local dining scene. Inside, you'll discover our top picks, complete with details on their signature dishes, atmosphere, price points, and insider tips. Whether you're planning a romantic waterfront dinner, a casual family outing, or just craving the freshest possible catch, this is your treasure map. We are here to help you explore the culinary gems that define Long Island seafood. Forget endless searching; your next unforgettable meal is just a scroll away.

1. Popei's Clam Bar (Bethpage)

Website: Popei's Clam Bar

Popei's Clam Bar in Bethpage is a well-known establishment in Nassau County, offering more than just a dining experience; it’s a culinary tradition. For many years, it has been the go-to place for those in search of enormous servings of fresh seafood in a bustling, lively, and casual environment. This is the spot for casual gatherings with friends to enjoy heaps of shellfish rather than intimate dinners.

Why It Stands Out

Popei's is celebrated for its commitment to offering abundant meals without compromising quality. The portions are famously large, ensuring no one leaves unsatisfied. Their "All You Can Eat" snow crab leg special is a highlight, attracting visitors from across Long Island. The lively and entertaining atmosphere makes it perfect for group outings and family events focused on excellent food and fun times.

The website is simple, reflecting their straightforward approach, providing necessary information like menus, hours, and directions. However, the authentic experience is in-person.

Signature Dishes & Local Tips

Though the crab legs are a major attraction, the menu offers a wide variety of must-try dishes. The fried calamari is a local favorite, known for its crispy and golden texture. For an authentic Long Island meal, try the steamers or the grand lobster dinner.

Key Information

Popei's Clam Bar continues to be a standout seafood restaurant in Nassau County, delivering a consistently satisfying experience centered on generous, quality seafood.

2. Bigelow’s New England Fried Clams (Rockville Centre)

Website: Bigelow’s New England Fried Clams

A staple in Rockville Centre, Bigelow’s New England Fried Clams offers a taste of New England right in Nassau County. Known for its charming, rustic atmosphere and dedication to preserving authentic flavors, this spot is perfect for seafood lovers seeking genuine fried clams and other traditional dishes in a cozy setting.

Why It Stands Out

Bigelow’s is celebrated for its rich history and commitment to quality. Since opening its doors, it has specialized in delivering authentic New England-style seafood, particularly its renowned fried clams. The restaurant’s inviting ambiance and classic diner feel make it a beloved destination for locals and visitors alike, offering a warm and nostalgic dining experience.

Signature Dishes & Local Tips

The standout feature at Bigelow’s is its signature fried clams, prepared using a time-honored recipe that has delighted patrons for years. Other must-try items include the clam chowder, famous for its creamy texture and rich flavor, and the fresh lobster roll, which captures the essence of New England cuisine.

Key Information

Bigelow’s New England Fried Clams is a cherished part of Rockville Centre’s dining scene, offering a slice of New England with its authentic and hearty seafood dishes.

3. Jordan Lobster Farms (Island Park)

Website: Jordan Lobster Farms

Located in Island Park, Jordan Lobster Farms is a seafood lover's paradise, known for its fresh catch and scenic waterfront views. Established with a focus on quality and freshness, this venue is a prime destination for those seeking an exceptional seafood experience in a laid-back, picturesque setting.

Why It Stands Out

Jordan Lobster Farms is distinguished by its commitment to offering the freshest seafood, sourced directly from local waters. The restaurant's charming setting by the water adds to its appeal, providing a serene backdrop for enjoying a meal. Known for its market-style service, patrons can select their own seafood, guaranteeing a fresh and personalized dining experience.

Signature Dishes & Local Tips

The restaurant's signature dishes include the classic lobster roll, overflowing with tender lobster meat, and the seafood platter, a generous assortment of the ocean's best offerings. The clam bake is another highlight, delivering a hearty and flavorful taste of a seaside tradition.

Key Information

Jordan Lobster Farms remains a top choice for seafood aficionados in Island Park, offering an unmatched combination of freshness, flavor, and a stunning waterfront location.

4. Limani (Roslyn)

Website: Limani

In the heart of Roslyn, Limani offers a taste of the Mediterranean with a focus on fresh seafood and elegant presentations. Known for its sophisticated dining experience, Limani captures the essence of coastal Mediterranean flavors in a luxurious setting, making it a preferred destination for special occasions and fine dining.

Why It Stands Out

Limani stands out for its dedication to authentic Mediterranean cuisine, emphasizing fresh, high-quality seafood dishes that transport diners to the shores of Greece. The restaurant’s chic and modern ambiance, complemented by attentive service, creates an unforgettable dining experience perfect for celebrating milestones or indulging in an upscale meal.

Signature Dishes & Local Tips

Signature dishes at Limani include the whole grilled fish, prepared simply to highlight the natural flavors, and the seafood tower, a stunning display of the ocean's finest offerings. The grilled octopus, tender and perfectly seasoned, is a must-try for those seeking a unique taste of the Mediterranean.

Key Information

Limani in Roslyn is a premier choice for those seeking an elegant and authentic Mediterranean seafood experience, offering exquisite dishes in a refined setting.

5. Anchor Down Seafood Bar & Grill (Merrick)

Website: Anchor Down Seafood Bar & Grill

Situated in Merrick, Anchor Down Seafood Bar & Grill offers a welcoming atmosphere and a menu brimming with fresh, flavorful dishes. This local favorite is known for its friendly service and commitment to quality, making it a go-to spot for casual dining and seafood indulgence.

Why It Stands Out

Anchor Down is celebrated for its relaxed vibe and dedication to serving fresh, delicious seafood in a casual setting. The restaurant’s emphasis on local ingredients and community spirit creates a warm and inviting atmosphere where guests can enjoy a satisfying meal with friends and family.

Signature Dishes & Local Tips

The menu at Anchor Down features standout dishes like the famous fish tacos, bursting with flavor, and the seafood paella, a hearty dish packed with a variety of the ocean's best. The raw bar, offering fresh oysters and clams, is a highlight for seafood enthusiasts.

Key Information

Anchor Down Seafood Bar & Grill in Merrick remains a beloved choice for locals and visitors alike, offering fresh seafood and a friendly atmosphere perfect for any occasion.

6. Ocean (East Rockaway)

Website: Ocean

Located in East Rockaway, Ocean offers a contemporary dining experience with a focus on fresh seafood and innovative dishes. Known for its chic interior and creative menu, this restaurant is a hotspot for those seeking fresh flavors and a modern take on classic seafood.

Why It Stands Out

Ocean is distinguished by its stylish ambiance and commitment to culinary creativity. The restaurant's modern décor and lively atmosphere make it a standout choice for diners looking to enjoy fresh seafood in a vibrant setting. Ocean’s emphasis on fresh ingredients and inventive recipes sets it apart as a destination for both locals and visitors.

Signature Dishes & Local Tips

Ocean’s menu includes signature dishes like the seafood risotto, rich and creamy with a delightful mix of seafood, and the tuna tartare, a refreshing appetizer that highlights the fish’s natural flavor. The grilled swordfish, expertly prepared and seasoned, is another favorite among patrons.

Key Information

Ocean in East Rockaway is a must-visit for those seeking a modern seafood experience, offering inventive dishes and a chic dining environment.

7. Peter’s Clam Bar (Island Park)

Website: Peter’s Clam Bar

Peter’s Clam Bar in Island Park is a historic seafood destination, renowned for its classic dishes and inviting waterfront setting. With a rich history dating back decades, this establishment offers a nostalgic dining experience reminiscent of traditional seafood shacks but with a modern twist.

Why It Stands Out

Peter’s Clam Bar is celebrated for its long-standing tradition of serving fresh, high-quality seafood in a scenic location. The restaurant's waterfront setting provides a picturesque backdrop for enjoying a meal, while its commitment to preserving traditional recipes ensures an authentic taste. Known for its welcoming atmosphere, Peter’s is a favorite among locals and visitors seeking a taste of the sea.

Signature Dishes & Local Tips

The clam bar’s signature offerings include the classic clam chowder, rich and satisfying, and the fried clam strips, a beloved favorite among patrons. The lobster roll, generously filled with fresh lobster meat, is another must-try dish that captures the essence of coastal dining.

Key Information

Peter’s Clam Bar in Island Park is a beloved seafood destination, offering a rich blend of history, flavor, and scenic views that make for an unforgettable dining experience.

Making Your Final Selection: A Practical Checklist

As you prepare to dive into your next seafood experience, consider these final steps to refine your choice. This process involves crafting an unforgettable dining experience.

• Cross-Check Menus & Specials: Visit the official websites or social media pages of Popei’s Clam Bar, Bigelow’s, Jordan Lobster Farms, Limani, Anchor Down, Ocean, and Peter’s Clam Bar to view seasonal catches and daily deals. This ensures you have the latest offerings.

• Evaluate for the Occasion: Decide based on the event—Popei’s, Peter’s, and Bigelow’s are ideal for family outings; Limani and Ocean suit a date night; Anchor Down and Jordan Lobster Farms are great for group celebrations.

• Consider Reservations vs. Walk-In: Limani and Ocean require reservations, while Popei’s and Bigelow’s welcome walk-ins. Arriving early can help you secure a spot without a wait.

• Think About Atmosphere: Choose based on the ambiance—enjoy nostalgic and casual vibes at Bigelow’s and Peter’s, indulge in upscale elegance at Limani, experience lively community-friendly settings at Anchor Down, or savor scenic waterfront views at Jordan Lobster Farms and Ocean.

• Timing Matters: Be mindful of busy periods like weekends and summer nights. Arriving early or calling ahead can help avoid lengthy waits.

By focusing on these aspects, you transform a simple choice into a well-informed decision. Your perfect seafood meal is just a thoughtful selection away.

Ready to dive deeper into what our community has to offer? For a curated directory of top-tier local businesses, from the best eateries to essential home services, explore the 516 Update All-Star Business Directory. Discover more trusted Nassau County gems and support the local businesses that make our area unique by visiting 516 Update.