8 Spots for the Best Wings on Long Island (2025 Guide)

Welcome to the comprehensive guide for every chicken wing enthusiast on Long Island. Our goal is to find the crispiest, sauciest, and most flavorful wings from Nassau to Suffolk County. Whether you enjoy the spicy kick of classic buffalo, the complex flavors of a gourmet dry rub, or a unique sauce that defies description, this list is your map to wing heaven.

Forget endless searching and unreliable reviews. We've done the tasty legwork, visiting local favorites and well-known spots to bring you a curated list of eateries that truly satisfy. This article is your direct route to discovering the absolute best wings on Long Island, focusing exclusively on brick-and-mortar places that prioritize quality and flavor. Each spot on our list is a verified local restaurant with a physical location, guaranteeing an authentic and satisfying dining experience every time.

In this guide, you will find:

• Top-tier wing destinations across both Nassau and Suffolk.

• Detailed descriptions of their signature sauces and unique preparations.

• Insider tips on what makes each location a must-visit for wing lovers.

Prepare to explore Long Island's most celebrated wing joints. Your quest for the perfect wing begins now.

1. Anchor Down (Seaford)

Anchor Down is a well-established venue in Seaford, known for its nautical-themed sports bar and restaurant setting, and is reputed for serving some of the best wings in the vicinity. It is a local go-to spot for its laid-back vibe, especially during game days, with a primary focus on perfecting their wings. The loyal customer base reflects their consistent delivery of crispy wings with a variety of flavorful sauces.

What sets Anchor Down apart is their cooking technique, which ensures the perfect texture in every wing. Each batch is fried to a golden-brown crisp, maintaining a satisfying crunch even when generously sauced. Patrons can select between traditional bone-in wings or boneless, both prepared with great attention to detail that keeps customers returning.

Flavor and Variety

The sauce menu at Anchor Down features a wide range of heat levels and flavor profiles, catering to diverse tastes. They offer more than standard options with unique, noteworthy house-made creations. Some of their most popular choices include:

• Signature Anchor Down Sauce: A medium-heat sauce that provides a classic tangy flavor with a slight kick, making it a versatile choice.

• Death Wish: For those who enjoy extreme heat, this sauce delivers an intense and fiery experience, not for the faint-hearted.

• Honey Garlic: A milder option that combines the sweetness of honey with the savory impact of garlic, creating a sticky, delicious glaze that is always in demand.

Their wide selection ensures that whether you prefer classic, mild, or intensely hot wings, you'll find something to suit your taste.

Insider Tips

To enhance your experience, request your wings extra crispy for maximum crunch. If you're undecided about flavors, try the wing flight to sample various signature sauces. Note that this is a popular spot, so it's advisable to arrive early on game days to secure a table, as seating is typically first-come, first-served.

Location: 2479 Adler Ct, Seaford, NY 11783 | Phone: 516-785-2390 | Website

2. Blackbird Kitchen + Bar (Wantagh)

Blackbird Kitchen + Bar in Wantagh offers an elevated dining experience, bringing a touch of sophistication to classic American comfort food. While renowned for its contemporary atmosphere and creative menu, Blackbird has earned a devoted following for serving some of the best wings on Long Island. This isn't a typical sports bar; instead, it's a place where classic pub fare is thoughtfully re-imagined with high-quality ingredients and chef-driven techniques, making their wings a standout dish.

The approach at Blackbird is centered on premium preparation and unique flavor combinations that appeal to a more refined palate. Their wings are meticulously cooked to achieve a perfect balance: crispy on the outside while remaining incredibly tender and juicy inside. This commitment to quality is evident in every bite, setting them apart from more conventional wing joints.

Flavor and Variety

Blackbird’s menu showcases a sophisticated departure from standard wing sauces, focusing on complex and memorable flavor profiles. Diners can expect inventive options that highlight culinary skill. Here are a few notable examples:

• Coffee-Rubbed Wings: A bold and aromatic dry rub featuring rich coffee notes, complemented by a sweet and smoky bourbon glaze for a truly unique taste.

• Dry-Rubbed Wings with Herb Seasoning: For those who prefer a crisp, non-sauced wing, this option is perfectly seasoned with a blend of savory herbs that enhances the natural flavor of the chicken.

• Buffalo Cauliflower: A fantastic alternative for vegetarians or anyone seeking a lighter option, these crispy cauliflower florets are tossed in a classic Buffalo sauce and served with blue cheese.

Insider Tips

To enhance your dining experience, pair your wings with one of Blackbird’s expertly crafted cocktails, as the flavor combinations are often designed to complement their bar program. The kitchen frequently experiments with new flavors, so be sure to ask your server about any seasonal sauce specials. Given the upscale nature of the menu, consider ordering the wings as a shared appetizer to kick off a larger meal.

Location: 3026 Merrick Rd, Wantagh, NY 11793 | Phone: (516) 654-9200 | Website

3. Croxley's Ale House (Farmingdale)

Croxley's Ale House is an institution on Long Island, synonymous with a classic American pub experience. This beloved beer hall has earned a legendary reputation for serving some of the best wings on Long Island, making it a non-negotiable stop for anyone serious about traditional Buffalo-style wings. The atmosphere is quintessential sports bar: energetic, welcoming, and always buzzing with patrons enjoying great beer and even better food.

At Croxley's, the focus is on perfecting the fundamentals. Their wings are celebrated for their consistent quality, fried to a perfect crispness on the outside while remaining tender and juicy inside. Unlike establishments that focus on experimental flavors, Croxley's prides itself on delivering an authentic, no-frills wing experience that has kept customers coming back for decades.

Flavor and Variety

Croxley’s menu honors the time-tested tradition of Buffalo wings, focusing on heat levels rather than an overwhelming variety of sauces. This approach ensures each batch is executed perfectly.

• Classic Buffalo: Available in mild, medium, hot, and "suicidal" heat levels, their signature sauce is tangy, buttery, and has the perfect spicy kick. It’s a purist’s dream.

• Honey BBQ: A sweet and smoky alternative for those who prefer flavor without the intense heat, this sauce offers a rich, satisfying glaze.

• Wing Challenges: For the truly brave, Croxley's occasionally hosts wing-eating challenges, testing the mettle of even the most seasoned chili-heads.

While their wings are a primary draw, their extensive menu offers something for everyone, from burgers to other pub classics. If you're exploring the local dining scene, you can also discover some of the best seafood restaurants in Nassau County nearby.

Insider Tips

To get the most out of your visit, take advantage of their famous wing nights, which offer incredible value. Arriving with a group is a great strategy, as it allows you to order multiple buckets of wings and sample different heat levels. Don’t forget to explore their massive craft beer selection; ask your server for a recommendation to pair with your chosen wing sauce.

Location: 190 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735 | Phone: (516) 293-7700 | Website

4. Hooters (Farmingdale)

While a global chain, the Hooters in Farmingdale has earned its place on Long Island by delivering a consistently classic and reliable wing experience. For decades, it has served as a go-to spot for groups seeking a lively atmosphere, sports on big screens, and a straightforward menu where their famous wings are the undisputed star. This consistency is a key reason many consider them a contender for some of the best wings on Long Island, offering a familiar and satisfying option every time.

Their signature process involves lightly breading the wings, deep-frying them to a perfect crisp, and then tossing them in your sauce of choice. This method creates a distinctive texture that has been perfected across their many locations, ensuring the quality remains the same. Patrons can choose between their classic "Original Hooters Style" wings or opt for boneless or "naked" (unbreaded) versions.

Flavor and Variety

Hooters' sauce lineup is iconic, offering a well-defined spectrum of heat levels and flavors that cater to nearly any preference. The sauces are graded by Scoville units, so you know exactly what you’re getting into.

• Original Hooters Medium: The quintessential Hooters sauce, this is the perfect middle-ground option with a classic cayenne pepper kick that is flavorful without being overwhelming.

• 3-Mile Island: For those who crave serious heat, this sauce delivers a fiery, lingering burn that will challenge even seasoned spice lovers.

• Honey BBQ: A great choice for a milder experience, this sauce offers a sweet, smoky, and tangy flavor profile that is a hit with all ages.

Insider Tips

To get the most out of your Hooters experience, start with the sampler platter if you are new to their sauces. It allows you to try a variety of their most popular flavors. Also, keep an eye out for location-specific promotions and events, especially during major sports seasons or for special deals like Nassau County Restaurant Week. This is an excellent option when you need a dependable and enjoyable wing outing that never disappoints. You can find more details about local dining events by checking out a guide on Nassau County Restaurant Week on 516update.com.

Location: 25 Smith St, Farmingdale, NY 11735 | Phone: 631-414-7792 | Website

5. Jake's Wayback Saloon (West Hempstead)

Jake's Wayback Saloon in West Hempstead offers a completely different, yet equally compelling, wing experience. This spot is a quintessential local dive bar, cherished for its no-frills atmosphere, affordable prices, and an unwavering focus on classic, perfectly executed wings. For those who believe the best wings on Long Island don't need fancy sauces or gourmet twists, Jake's is a true sanctuary.

The approach here is refreshingly simple and effective. The wings are known for being generously portioned, consistently crispy, and drenched in sauce. It's an old-school establishment that prioritizes quality and value over trends, making it a beloved institution among locals who appreciate an authentic neighborhood bar feel.

Flavor and Variety

Jake's doesn't overwhelm with a long list of experimental flavors; instead, it masters the classics that wing lovers crave. The focus is on doing a few things exceptionally well.

• Classic Buffalo: The star of the show. This is a traditional, perfectly balanced Buffalo sauce available in various heat levels, served with a generous side of chunky blue cheese.

• Hot Wings: For those who like to turn up the heat, their hot wings deliver a satisfying and straightforward kick without sacrificing flavor. Ordering them with extra sauce is a popular move.

• Simple BBQ: A classic, tangy, and slightly sweet BBQ sauce that provides a familiar and delicious alternative to the Buffalo-style options.

The charm of Jake's lies in its commitment to tradition, proving that sometimes the most memorable wings are the ones that stick to the fundamentals.

Insider Tips

To get the most out of your visit to Jake's, keep a few things in mind. This is a cash-only establishment, so be sure to visit an ATM beforehand. It's the ideal spot for a casual, laid-back experience and offers incredible value, making it a great choice for feeding large groups without breaking the bank. Don't expect fancy decor; just expect great wings and a friendly, local crowd.

Location: 512 Hempstead Turnpike, West Hempstead, NY 11552, United States | Phone: (516) 414-0441

6. Munday's (East Meadow)

Munday's has been a cherished East Meadow institution since 1985, earning its reputation as a go-to spot for some of the best wings on Long Island. This family-owned and operated pub has cultivated a fiercely loyal following by consistently delivering on two key promises: massive portions and exceptional house-made sauces. It’s a no-frills establishment where the focus is squarely on serving up high-quality, generously sized wings that keep customers coming back for decades.

The approach at Munday's is straightforward and effective. Their wings are known for being exceptionally large and meaty, fried to a perfect crispness before being drenched in sauce. The emphasis is on classic execution and satisfying portions, making it a reliable destination for anyone craving traditional pub-style wings done right.

Flavor and Variety

While Munday's keeps its sauce list classic, the quality and execution are what set them apart. Each sauce is crafted in-house, ensuring a fresh and distinct flavor profile that has stood the test of time. Here are some of the fan favorites:

• Signature Munday's Medium: The quintessential choice and the perfect introduction to their wings. It offers a balanced, tangy heat that is flavorful without being overwhelming.

• Extra Hot: For those who crave a serious kick, the extra hot sauce delivers an intense, lingering spice that will satisfy even the most seasoned heat-seekers.

• Mild Wings with Honey: A popular off-menu combination where patrons get the mild sauce and order a side of honey for dipping or drizzling, creating a custom sweet and savory flavor.

This commitment to traditional flavors, executed perfectly and served in abundance, is what has cemented Munday's legacy in the Long Island wing scene.

Insider Tips

To get the most out of your Munday's experience, remember that their wings are notoriously large and saucy, so ordering extra napkins is a must. Be sure to try their rich and creamy house-made blue cheese dressing, which is the perfect complement to their spicy sauces. The pub can get very busy, so visiting during off-peak hours often results in quicker service and a more relaxed atmosphere.

Location: 2590 Hempstead Turnpike, East Meadow, NY 11554 | Phone: (516) 520-1055 | Website

7. Brickhouse Brewery & Restaurant (Patchogue)

Brickhouse Brewery & Restaurant in Patchogue offers a unique and compelling experience for wing lovers, masterfully pairing artisanal wings with their own house-brewed craft beers. This establishment stands out by treating wings not just as a bar snack but as a culinary creation designed to complement their diverse beer portfolio. For those seeking some of the best wings on Long Island with a sophisticated twist, Brickhouse is a must-visit destination.

The philosophy here is synergy; each wing sauce is developed with a specific beer profile in mind, creating a harmonious tasting experience. Their wings are known for being perfectly crispy and substantial, providing the ideal canvas for their inventive, beer-infused sauces that you simply won't find anywhere else.

Flavor and Variety

Brickhouse's menu showcases a deep understanding of flavor pairing, leveraging the distinct characteristics of different beer styles to create unforgettable wing sauces. Here are some of their most celebrated offerings:

• IPA-Glazed Wings: These wings are coated in a vibrant glaze made from their own India Pale Ale, delivering a slightly bitter, hoppy finish that cuts through the richness of the chicken.

• Porter BBQ Wings: A classic barbecue sauce is given a robust upgrade with the addition of their dark, malty porter, imparting a deep, smoky flavor with notes of coffee and chocolate.

• Seasonal Ale Sauces: The brewery frequently rotates its taps, and the kitchen follows suit with limited-time wing sauces, such as a pumpkin ale sauce in the fall that offers a perfect blend of savory and spice.

As one of the standout establishments in Patchogue's thriving dining scene, Brickhouse Brewery & Restaurant consistently innovates its menu. To see how it compares to other local spots, you can learn more about new Long Island restaurants and their unique offerings.

Insider Tips

To elevate your experience, always ask your server for beer pairing recommendations for your chosen wing sauce. Be sure to inquire about any seasonal or off-menu sauces, as these are often the most creative. For the full experience, time your visit to coincide with a brewery tour to see where the magic begins.

Location: 67 W Main St, Patchogue, NY 11772 | Phone: (631) 447-2337 | Website

Top 8 Wings Spots Comparison

Your Guide to Long Island's Wing Scene

Long Island's culinary landscape is as diverse and vibrant as its communities, and nowhere is this more evident than in its incredible chicken wing scene. Our journey through Nassau and Suffolk counties has taken us from the innovative, gourmet creations at Blackbird Kitchen + Bar in Wantagh to the timeless, classic perfection served up at Munday's in East Meadow. We’ve explored the lively atmosphere and extensive sauce lists at mainstays like Croxley's Ale House and uncovered hidden gems like the smoked and grilled masterpieces at Anchor Down.

This guide was designed to be more than just a list; it’s a roadmap for your next flavor adventure. Whether you're a lifelong resident or a visitor exploring the area, the quest for the best wings on Long Island is a delicious pursuit with no wrong answers. Your personal favorite might be the perfectly crispy, straightforward wings from Jake's Wayback Saloon or the unique, chef-driven specials you'll find at Lola Burger & Wings. The beauty lies in the exploration itself.

Key Takeaways from Our Wing Tour

To make your next outing a success, keep these key insights in mind:

• Atmosphere Matters: The experience is about more than just the food. A place like Brickhouse Brewery in Patchogue offers a dynamic, social setting that pairs perfectly with its wings, while the cozy, local feel of a saloon or pub provides a more intimate dining experience. Consider the vibe you're looking for when making your choice.

• Don't Fear the Heat (or Lack Thereof): While classic Buffalo sauce is a benchmark, the best spots offer a wide spectrum of flavors. From sweet and tangy BBQ to complex garlic parmesan or fiery ghost pepper, there's a sauce for every palate. Don't be afraid to step outside your comfort zone and try a house specialty.

• The Best Wings Are Fresh Wings: The top-tier establishments on our list prioritize quality ingredients. They aren't just reheating frozen products; they're brining, smoking, and frying fresh wings to order. This commitment to quality is what separates a good wing from a great one.

Your Next Actionable Steps

Now it's your turn to join the delicious debate. We've given you the intel, but the only way to truly find the best wings on Long Island is to taste them for yourself.

1. Plan Your Wing Crawl: Pick two or three spots from our list that intrigued you the most. Maybe start with a classic pub and then visit a more modern kitchen to compare styles.

2. Order Strategically: When visiting a new place, ask your server for their recommendation or the most popular sauce. It’s often the one they’ve perfected.

3. Share Your Findings: The conversation around Long Island's food scene is always evolving. Share your photos, your ratings, and your new favorite spots with friends and online communities.

This curated exploration is a testament to the passion and creativity of local chefs and restaurateurs. By visiting these establishments, you're not just enjoying a fantastic meal; you're supporting the small businesses that make Long Island's dining culture so rich and exciting. So gather your friends, grab some napkins, and get ready to discover your personal champion in the delicious world of Long Island wings.

For the latest updates on restaurant openings, foodie events, and everything happening in your neighborhood, stay connected with 516 Update. We are your dedicated source for all things Nassau County, helping you discover the best local businesses, from wing joints to community festivals. Visit 516 Update to stay informed and never miss out on what's happening nearby.