A Guide to Jericho Cider Mill: Long Island's Favorite Fall Tradition

When the first crisp, cool breeze of autumn rolls across Long Island, locals know it’s time for a pilgrimage to a place that feels like the heart of the season itself: the Jericho Cider Mill. This isn't just a store; it’s an experience woven into the fabric of Nassau County’s most cherished traditions, a landmark where generations have come to welcome sweater weather with the comforting taste of fresh cider and warm donuts.

For over two centuries, the mill has been the unofficial start of fall, a cozy haven of comforting flavors we wait for all year long.

Experience the Heart of Autumn at Jericho Cider Mill

Walking into the Jericho Cider Mill is like getting a warm hug on a cool October day. The air is absolutely intoxicating—thick with the sweet perfume of cinnamon, baked apples, and freshly pressed cider. It’s a scent that instantly brings back memories of childhood visits and the simple joy of warm cider steam on a crisp October morning.

This is one of those classic Long Island spots where the charm is as authentic as the ingredients. You can feel the history in the rustic wooden beams and hear it in the gentle hum of happy customers. This is the place you come for the simple, perfect pleasures of the season.

A Sensory Autumn Experience

A trip to the mill is a true feast for the senses, a place defined by feelings and flavors that have remained wonderfully unchanged for decades.

Here’s what you can expect:

• The Scent: An unforgettable aroma of warm cider donuts just out of the fryer, mingling with the spicy notes of bubbling apple butter.

• The Taste: The pure, unfiltered sweetness of their famous cider is a must, as is the comforting warmth of a handmade pie.

• The Vibe: It’s just pure, nostalgic, family-friendly energy, making it one of the most beloved fall activities in Nassau County.

This infographic really gets to the heart of why the mill remains such a cornerstone of local autumn tradition.

The image perfectly captures the mill's timeless appeal. It's so much more than a store—it’s a destination where memories are made year after year.

If you're planning on making a full day of it, you can find more great ideas for what to do on Long Island this weekend to round out your visit.

Whether you’re craving warm cider or a taste of local tradition, Jericho Cider Mill is the perfect way to celebrate fall on Long Island.

A Rich History Pressed Into Every Bottle

When you take a sip of fresh-pressed apple cider Long Island style at the Jericho Cider Mill, you're tasting more than just apples. You're getting a taste of over two centuries of local history. Founded in the 1800s, this isn't just another old business; it's a living monument to Long Island’s agricultural roots, a place where tradition has been carefully preserved and passed down through generations.

The mill's story begins in the early 1800s, making it a true historical landmark. While countless other businesses have come and gone, the Jericho Cider Mill has remained a constant, weathering incredible changes over its long life. Its staying power is a testament to the community that loves it and the families who have poured their hearts into the craft. Every visit makes you part of that legacy, which is why it's one of the most meaningful fall activities in Nassau County.

A Legacy Spanning Centuries

The journey of this beloved mill is a fascinating slice of New York history. In fact, the Jericho Cider Mill is recognized as the oldest in the state and is on track to celebrate its 205th anniversary in 2025. The original mill was on Route 106, but it hit a major snag with the start of Prohibition in 1919. Even so, the tradition didn't die; a local farmer named John Hicks opened a new mill nearby to keep it alive. You can dive deeper into the mill's full history over at longislandpress.com.

That deep commitment to tradition is what defines the place. For most of its life, the mill has been a family-run operation, with local legends like 'Farmer' John Zulkofske and his son George at the helm. In 2015, Ted Ketsoglou took over, making sure the mill's time-honored methods would continue. Today, they press over 40,000 gallons of cider every year—a massive number that shows just how important it is among Long Island cider mills.

Preserving Time-Honored Traditions

So, what makes the Jericho Cider Mill so special? It’s their unwavering dedication to doing things the old-fashioned way. In a world obsessed with speed and mass production, the mill stands its ground, focusing on authentic, handcrafted quality.

You can feel that history the moment you walk in. You won't find any shiny, modern machinery here. Instead, you’ll see a process that has been fine-tuned over decades, all centered on one simple goal: making the purest, most flavorful cider you can find. It’s that dedication that turns a quick stop into a cherished tradition.

The story of the mill is really the story of Long Island itself—one of resilience, community, and a deep love for simple things done well. Every jug of cider and every warm donut carries a piece of that history with it.

A visit is more than an errand; it’s an opportunity to connect with a piece of Long Island’s history and support a local legend.

A Taste of the Season: What to Get at the Mill

The moment you walk into the Jericho Cider Mill, that unmistakable smell of cinnamon, apples, and baked goods hits you. It’s a sensory overload in the best possible way. The real challenge isn’t finding something you want; it’s trying to decide what to leave behind.

Let's start with the headliner: the cider. This isn't the stuff you get in a carton at the supermarket. This is pure, fresh-pressed apple cider Long Island style, and it tastes exactly like fall. You can grab a classic gallon jug to take home or, my personal favorite, get a steaming hot cup to warm your hands on a crisp afternoon.

The Legendary Cider Donuts

Honestly, you can't say you've been to the Jericho Cider Mill if you haven't had their cider donuts. They are truly in a class of their own. Made fresh all day long, these donuts have a warm, unbelievably soft, and cakey texture that just dissolves in your mouth.

Each one gets a generous dusting of cinnamon and sugar that catches the light and adds the perfect sweet crunch. Grabbing a bag of these is basically a requirement. They’re so iconic that local hotels, like The Vanderbilt with its "Fall Family Adventure Package," even feature them to give guests a true taste of Long Island.

Whether you tear into them in the car or manage to save some for later, these donuts are a huge reason the mill is a go-to spot for fall activities in Nassau County.

Pies, Produce, and Perfect Autumn Flavors

While the cider and donuts get most of the glory, the mill's country store is packed with other treasures. The shelves are loaded with incredible homemade pies, each one a perfect example of classic baking. You can't go wrong with traditional apple or apple crumb, but seasonal favorites like pumpkin are just as fantastic. They make a perfect centerpiece for any fall get-together.

Beyond the big-ticket items, the rustic store is filled with other local goodies:

• Candy and Caramel Apples: That classic, sticky, sweet-and-tart fall treat.

• Local Honey: Straight from nearby hives, it's a pure taste of Long Island terroir.

• Fresh Produce: Depending on the week, you’ll find pumpkins, gourds, and other fresh-picked vegetables.

• Jams and Apple Butter: Absolutely perfect for slathering on toast on a cool morning.

Why not make a whole day of it? After loading up on treats at the mill, you could check out some of the best brunch spots in Nassau County and turn your visit into a full-blown culinary tour.

With so much to choose from, it can be a little overwhelming for a first-timer. Here’s a quick guide to the essentials you absolutely have to try.

Your First Visit Must-Try Menu

No matter what you're craving, a trip to Jericho Cider Mill is the perfect way to dive headfirst into the flavors of a Long Island autumn.

More Than a Mill: A Hub for Local Agriculture

It’s easy to think of the Jericho Cider Mill as just the home of incredible cider and warm donuts. While those treats are certainly a huge draw, the mill’s role in our community runs much, much deeper. Behind that charming, rustic storefront is a vital partner for farms all across New York.

This commitment to sourcing locally is what makes everything here taste so authentic. Each bottle of cider creates a tangible connection between your family and the farmers who grew the apples. When you shop here, you're not just buying a taste of autumn; you're actively supporting the local economy and helping to preserve Long Island's agricultural heritage.

A Commitment to Local and Regional Farms

The sheer scale of the mill’s operation is pretty staggering, and it really highlights their dedication to the farming community. The vast majority of apples pressed on-site come from the fertile Hudson Valley, one of New York's absolute best apple-growing regions. This long-standing partnership gives farmers a reliable place to sell their harvest, ensuring all that hard work finds its way to an appreciative home.

This isn't just a quaint little operation. The Jericho Cider Mill is a major player in the local agricultural economy. Think about this: they process approximately 40 to 45 bins of apples per batch, and each of those bins weighs about 800 pounds. That incredible volume makes it a cornerstone of the Long Island cider mills network. You can even explore its role in regional industry to get a better sense of its impact.

More Than Apples: A Seasonal Showcase

And it’s not just about the apples. The mill’s country store is a constantly changing showcase of the best our region has to offer.

• Pumpkins and Gourds: In the fall, the mill is bursting with pumpkins of all shapes and sizes, perfect for carving or decorating your front porch.

• Local Honey: You'll find shelves stocked with beautiful jars of golden honey from nearby apiaries, offering a pure taste of Long Island's wildflowers.

• Seasonal Produce: Depending on the time of year, you might also find other fresh fruits and vegetables sourced directly from neighboring farms.

This focus on local goods has made the mill a central part of so many family traditions. People come for cider in the fall, and then many return for other seasonal staples. For instance, if you're already thinking about the holidays, our guide to the best Christmas tree farms on Long Island can help you find another cherished local experience.

Whether you're after a warm cider donut or just want to feel connected to local tradition, a trip to the Jericho Cider Mill is a perfect way to celebrate the season.

Planning Your Perfect Fall Visit

A trip to the Jericho Cider Mill is a real Long Island rite of passage, and with a little inside knowledge, you can make your visit go off without a hitch. It’s one of those wonderfully rustic places that feels spontaneous, but knowing the ropes means less time waiting in line and more time soaking up that incredible autumn feeling. Think of this as your local's guide to a perfect day at one of the island's most treasured fall spots.

There’s just something about the mill. The second you step out of your car on a crisp October morning, the smell of warm cider hits you. It's a place where you can slow down and just enjoy the simple things that make the season great.

Best Times to Visit and Beating the Crowds

Let’s be real: everyone loves the Jericho Cider Mill, especially on a perfect fall weekend. By mid-October, you can expect lines snaking out the door as families arrive for their favorite fall activities in Nassau County.

If you'd rather have a more laid-back experience, here’s when you should go:

• Weekday Afternoons: This is the golden ticket. A weekday visit gives you room to breathe, browse the store at your own pace, and actually chat with the staff without feeling rushed.

• Early Weekend Mornings: If the weekend is your only shot, get there right when they open. You’ll sidestep the afternoon chaos and, most importantly, get your hands on the freshest donuts first.

Navigating Parking and Payments

Parking can get a little tricky during peak hours. The mill has its own lot, but it fills up fast on busy days. You can find street parking nearby, but pay close attention to the signs and expect a short, scenic walk. Arriving early isn't just about avoiding lines—it's also your best bet for snagging a good parking spot.

Part of the mill's old-school charm is how they do business. For as long as most of us can remember, it's been a cash-only spot. They usually have an ATM on-site, but coming with cash in hand is the fastest way to get your cider, pies, and donuts and get on with your day.

Making a Day of It: What’s Nearby

While the mill is a destination in itself, its central Jericho location makes it easy to build a whole day around your visit. Once you’ve loaded up on treats, why not explore some of the beautiful spots nearby to round out your fall adventure?

Consider heading over to Cantiague Park or Bethpage State Park, both of which are just a quick drive away. They have fantastic walking trails perfect for admiring the fall colors. It's the ideal way to walk off a few of those cider donuts while taking in even more of what makes Long Island beautiful in the fall.

We encourage you to plan a visit this weekend. Whether you’re craving warm cider or a taste of local tradition, Jericho Cider Mill is the perfect way to celebrate fall on Long Island.

Your Questions About Jericho Cider Mill Answered

So, you're planning a trip to the Jericho Cider Mill? Fantastic choice. It's one of those classic Long Island experiences that just screams autumn. But before you head out, you probably have a few questions. I've been going for years, so I've heard them all.

Let's get the practical stuff sorted out. That way, you can spend less time wondering and more time enjoying that amazing cider-and-donut smell that hits you the second you get out of the car. Here’s the inside scoop on what you need to know.

Does Jericho Cider Mill Offer Apple Picking?

This is easily the most common question I hear, and the answer is no. The Jericho Cider Mill is a historic press and a country store, not a pick-your-own farm. Think of it as the place you go after the apples have been picked.

While they don't have an orchard for visitors, they sell bags and bushels of incredible, fresh-picked apples from local growers. They focus on their true craft: pressing those apples into the best apple cider Long Island has to offer.

Is Jericho Cider Mill Open Year-Round?

Nope, and that’s part of its charm. The mill is a seasonal spot, and its opening is one of the first signs that fall has truly arrived. Its schedule is tied directly to the apple harvest.

• Opening Season: The doors usually swing open in late August or early September.

• Peak Season: September through November is prime time, when the mill is buzzing with activity.

• Closing Season: Once the harvest season wraps up, they typically close for the winter.

The exact dates can shift a bit each year, so your best bet is to always check their official website or social media before making the drive.

What Is the Best Time to Visit to Avoid Crowds?

Let's be honest: on a beautiful fall weekend in October, this place is the place to be. It gets packed. If you want a more laid-back experience without the long lines, try visiting on a weekday afternoon.

If the weekend is your only option, I have one piece of advice: go early. Arriving right when they open in the morning is the best way to beat the big rush and snag those donuts when they're at their freshest.

Does the Mill Accept Credit Cards?

This is a big one. The Jericho Cider Mill is famously old-school and has always been a cash-only spot. It really adds to that authentic, step-back-in-time feeling.

They usually have an ATM on-site, but I strongly recommend bringing cash with you. It just makes everything quicker and easier, so you can get straight to the good stuff.

From warm cider to pies that taste like they came straight from grandma's kitchen, the Jericho Cider Mill is the perfect way to embrace autumn on Long Island.

Stay connected with all the best local spots and events with 516 Update, your go-to source for everything happening in Nassau County. Discover more at https://516update.com.